Detalles de la publicación

Datos del artículo o publicación


The Struggle for a voice: tensions between associations and citizens in participatory budgeting (2013)

participatory democracy, associations, citizens

The emergence of new participatory mechanisms, such as participatory budgeting, in towns and cities in recent years, has given rise to a conflict between the old protagonists of local participation and the new citizens invited to participate. These mechanisms offer a logic of collective action different to what has been the usual fare in the cities – one that is based on proposal rather than demand. As a result, it requires urban social movements to transform their own dynamics in order to make room for a new political subject (the citizenry and the non-organised participant) and to act upon a stage where deliberative dynamics now apply. The present article aims to analyse this conflict in three different cities that set up participatory budgeting at different times: Porto Alegre, Córdoba and Paris. The associations in the three cities took up a position against the new participatory mechanism and demanded a bigger role in the political arena. Through a piece of ethnographic research, we shall see that the responses of the agents involved (politicians, associations and citizens) in the three cities share some arguments, although the conflict was resolved differently in each of them. The article concludes with reflections on the consequences this conflict could have for contemporary political theory, especially with respect to the role of associations in the processes of democratisation and the setting forth of a new way of doing politics by means of deliberative procedures.




Ganuza, E; Nez, H; Morales, E


articulos post-print


International Journal of Urban and Regional Research


Enlace aquí




articulos post-print



Otras publicaciones

Otros artículos y publicaciones del IESA

El sistema de cuidados en Andalucía

El artículo trata de exponer y evaluar el actual sistema de cuidados en Andalucía.

Agricultura familiar en España. Anuario 2016.

La publicación del Anuario de 2016 de UPA, con el lema, “Agricultura y mundo rural: experiencias ...

La integración del colectivo inmigrante en las regiones españolas

Este artículo presenta un novedoso sistema de medición de la integración de las personas ...

Economic Crisis and Anti-Immigrant Sentiment: The Case of Andalusia

This paper provides three interrelated reasons not to confound perceptions of economic group-threat ...

Popular Democracy. The Paradox of Participation

Stanford University Press has recently published Popular Democracy. The Paradox of Participation. ...

Tolerating the Intolerant: Homophily, Intolerance and Segregation in Social Balanced Networks

We model a community of individuals whose relationships are governed by the rules of the so-called ...